The True Meaning of a Hero: A Comparative Study

When we speak of heroes, the mental image that comes to mind is often far removed from the current debates surrounding George Floyd. Heroes are supposed to uphold principles of honor, sacrifice, and service. Tragically, modern media has contaminated this definition, leading to a grave misinterpretation. In this article, we will explore the true essence of heroism through the lens of Sergeant William H Carney, a Civil War veteran, and compare his bravery to the contend of George Floyd's legacy.

Modern Misinterpretation of Heroism

It is pertinent to mention that in today's society, the term 'hero' is often misapplied. This is particularly evident in the posthumous labeling of George Floyd as a hero. Critics argue that such a label is an affront to the true meaning of heroism. The narrative surrounding George Floyd portrays him as a symbol of ‘police brutality and black excellence’. While this romanticization may provide some solace and a sense of cultural pride, it also perpetuates a harmful narrative that glorifies criminal behavior.

The Life and Death of George Floyd

George Floyd’s name is often linked with the narrative of a man who died under police custody. However, this does not encompass the entirety of his life and values. The underlying context is that he was addicted to fentanyl and not attending to his own children. Such factors detract from the notion of heroism as traditionally understood, where a hero prioritizes moral values and public service.

Sergeant William H Carney: A True Hero

To truly understand who a hero is, we should look at figures like Sergeant William H Carney, a Civil War veteran who exemplified the ideals of service and bravery. At the Battle of Fort Wagner, Sergeant Carney refused to allow the American flag to be captured, even as he was wounded multiple times. His unwavering bravery and love for his nation led to his being awarded the Medal of Honor. Carney’s actions were driven by a deep-seated sense of duty and national pride, not personal gain or self-aggrandizement.

Legacy and Memory

Carney's legacy lives on in songs and stories that commemorate his courage. Consider the following excerpt from a song celebrating his valor:

"One night on Southern battlefields, down where Fort Wagner lay A regiment of black men fought The Blue against the Gray. As the sun sank slowly in the West, A thunderstorm and gale Wept tears to see the brave black troops Shot down by leaden hail. A negro saw the old flag fall And threw his gun away To grasp the falling colors staff And lead them to the fray. Twas the Blue against the Gray boys And he said to all around The old flag never touched the ground. He said to all around The old flag never touched the ground."

This poem encapsulates the dedication and sacrifice of Sergeant Carney, who fought for the principles of liberty and unity, rather than for personal or racial gain.

Conclusion: The Complexity of Heroes

The story of George Floyd and Sergeant William H Carney serve as stark reminders of the complexity and diversity of heroes. While George Floyd’s spirit evokes a poignant narrative of systemic injustice, the legacy of Sergeant Carney offers a profound example of selfless service and valor. The true spirit of a hero lies in the principles they uphold, the sacrifices they make, and the values they champion. We should strive to honor and remember these true heroes who embody the best of what it means to serve and protect, rather than those who misguidedly claim the title of hero for their own gain.