Why the Faceless Men of Game of Thrones Did Not Kick Arya Out

One of the enduring mysteries in the Game of Thrones series revolves around why the Faceless Men, specifically Jaqen Hghar, did not kick Arya Stark out of the House of Black and White. Throughout the show, there are numerous reasons why the Faceless Men continued to train and support Arya, despite her initial struggles to become 'no one.'

Potential

Arya Stark shows significant potential as an assassin. Her skills and determination make her a valuable asset to the Faceless Men, even if she faces challenges in understanding the concept of being 'no one.' The Faceless Men recognize this potential and see in Arya the makings of a powerful assassin. She possesses a tenacity and a desire to prove herself, qualities that the Faceless Men find both intriguing and useful.

Test of Resolve

The Faceless Men often test individuals to determine if they are truly willing to abandon their past identities and embrace their new ones. Arya's journey through Westeros and her experiences with different killers and assassins serve as a trial. The Faceless Men may believe that Arya needs to face her own motivations and desires before fully committing to their way of life. This process is central to her character development, and the patience and guidance of Jaqen Hghar play a crucial role in Arya's growth.

Personal Interest

At the core, Jaqen Hghar has a personal interest in Arya Stark. He sees her as someone who could ultimately embrace the teachings of the Faceless Men and wants to guide her through her internal conflicts. Instead of simply expelling her, Jaqen takes a mentorship role, helping Arya navigate the complexities of her new identity and the challenges she faces. This personal investment underscores the Faceless Men's belief that Arya has a unique potential that makes her worth the effort.

Philosophy of Choice

The Faceless Men operate on a philosophy that emphasizes choice. They might believe that Arya must come to the realization of what it means to become 'no one' on her own terms. The Faceless Men respect the journey and the process of becoming a true assassin. They recognize that true change isn't something that can be forced upon someone. Rather, it must be a personal choice and a result of overcoming one's own internal struggles. This philosophy is reflected in the patience and support they provide to Arya, even as she grapples with her identity and past.

Conclusion

Arya Stark's struggle with her identity and her past is central to her character arc. The Faceless Men's patience reflects the complexity of this journey. In the broader context of the series, it is possible that the Faceless Men were given a prophecy or recognized Arya's potential. They allowed her to leave and return to being Arya Stark with the hope that she would continue to grow and develop as an assassin. While the show may leave some questions unanswered, the underlying reasons for the Faceless Men's support are complex and multifaceted.

Additionally, there is a possibility that the Faceless Men want Arya as much as she wants them. Their recognition of her skills as a skin changer and her abilities as an assassin likely played a significant role in their continued support. The Faceless Men value experiences and unique talents, making Arya a valuable asset even if her progress is slow. This reciprocal relationship between Arya and the Faceless Men adds another layer of depth to her character development.