Why Some People Dislike Citizen Kane: Analyzing the Challenges and Reactions

Since its release in 1941, Citizen Kane has become a landmark in cinematic history, praised by many as a masterpiece. However, it has faced criticism from various quarters, sparking debates among movie enthusiasts and scholars. In this article, we delve into the reasons why some people dislike Citizen Kane

Challenges in Viewing Citizen Kane

The film's complex narrative and unconventional storytelling have often been cited as reasons for viewers' dissatisfaction. Citizen Kane's non-linear storytelling and the use of flashbacks can create a pacing issue that some find slow or uneven. This experimental approach to storytelling challenges viewers accustomed to more traditional narrative techniques, leading to a sense of disorientation and discomfort.

Complexity of the Characters

The character of Charles Foster Kane is a central feature of the film, but his complexity and the disparity between his early life of privilege and his later isolation can be difficult for some viewers to empathize with. His journey through life, marked by various failures and disillusionment, may not resonate with everyone. Consequently, some viewers find the protagonist's character arc challenging to follow, leading to a lack of emotional connection.

Experimental Cinematography

Orson Welles' innovative use of filming techniques, such as deep focus and unconventional angles, adds a layer of complexity to the film. However, these experimental techniques can be jarring or distracting for some viewers who prefer more traditional cinematography. The innovative approach to visual storytelling may alienate viewers who are more accustomed to conventional film-making.

Themes of Isolation and Disillusionment

The film's exploration of themes such as the emptiness of wealth and the pursuit of happiness can be perceived as bleak and overly pessimistic or cynical by some viewers. The disillusionment and isolation depicted in Kane's life may not appeal to audiences looking for a more uplifting narrative. This thematic content has been seen by some as a reflection of the dark realities of life, which can be unsettling for viewers.

Historical Context and Controversy

When the film was released, there was a controversial reception due to its culturally subversive nature, which diverged from the rosy picture of America that the public was used to. According to many historians, the film was not well-received by the general public. The unique narrative and characters were unfamiliar and difficult to relate to, leading to a lukewarm response in the film's initial release. The film had a difficult time at the box office, partially because it was perceived as an attack on the powerful newspaper magnate, William Randolph Hearst.

Hearst was enraged by the film, seeing it as a thinly veiled attack on his life. He wielded his influence to attack the film and the filmmakers. Hearst's newspapers and powerful film critics spread negative propaganda against the film, dissuading theater owners from showing it. This political and media backlash added to the film's challenges in gaining mainstream acceptance.

Despite the initial criticism, Citizen Kane has since garnered a reputation as one of the greatest films ever made. It was nominated for several Oscars and won the Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay. Its impact on film history was significant, and re-releases in the 1950s and beyond helped to solidify its place in the canon of cinematic achievements.

In summary, while Citizen Kane has become a legendary film, its complex narrative, innovative techniques, and challenging themes initially presented challenges to critics and viewers. However, over time, its enduring appeal and historic significance have made it a celebrated masterpiece of cinema.