Why Dislike the Percy Jackson Movies' Shipping: A Fan Perspective

In the vast fan community surrounding Percy Jackson, the concept of shipping has sparked numerous debates and discussions. Most notably, fans of the series often criticize certain ship pairings, especially when they involve minor characters and adults. This article delves into why some fans dislike the relationship between Percy and Nico, considered by many to be more platonic or innocent, and how these feelings tie into broader themes within the fandom.

The Fan Reaction

One of the common reasons behind the negative reaction to Percy and Nico as a couple (or even a romantic pairing) is the age gap and the presence of adult characters. Many fans feel that this type of ship is inappropriate and against the general community norms, especially when it involves a minor and an adult. This sentiment is further exacerbated by the popularity of alternate ships such as Percabeth (Percy Jackson and Annabeth Chase) and Solangelo (Solomon and Nico_diAngelo).

Motivations Behind the Criticism

1. Protective Fandom

A large percentage of the Percabeth shippers are extremely protective of their favorite ship. This deep loyalty can lead to strong reactions against any deviation from the ship's character compatibility. Discussions involving alternative pairings such as Perimis, Perthalia, or Percico might trigger anger or annoyance from these fans.

2. Union of Minor and Adult

The ship's nature of involving a minor character (like Nico) and an adult character (such as Percy, Annabeth, or Will) often goes against the general perception of what constitutes a healthy and appropriate relationship. This is particularly sensitive in a young audience that appreciates clear moral and thematic boundaries.

3. Percy's Sexual Orientation

Another factor is Percy's established sexuality as someone who dates girls and not boys. This has led to intense criticism and controversy within the Percy Jackson fandom from both Percabeth and Non-Percabeth shippers alike. The pairing of Percy and Nico challenges these established norms and can be seen as a violation of character consistency.

Personal Insights and Explanations

Some fans, like Eloise Thomson, provide detailed insights into the pairings, suggesting that while Nico had a crush on Percy, it was more innocent and platonic. They argue that crushes fade over time and that Nico's current felt younger at the time of the crush, suggesting that as Nico matures, his interest would naturally shift. In contrast, it is noted that the relationship between Nico and Will is seen as more cute and agreeable, pointing to a more suitable match for Nico's character development in the series.

Personal experience:

A detail from the series suggests that Nico and Percy might have had a few awkward moments due to recent events, such as after Bianca's death, which might have caused confusion and innocent feelings from Nico's side.

Conclusion:

Despite the popularity of Percy and Nico as a Percy and Nico ship, the fandom remains divided on the topic. The criticism and dislike revolve around the perceived inappropriateness of day-olds and the alignment with established character traits. Regardless of opinions, it is essential for creators and authors to maintain consistency with character development and reader expectations.

Thank you for your understanding and engagement.
Here's a Percabeth image for your continued support.

- Eloise Thomson