Which 2019 Movie Deserves the 2020 Academy Award for Best Picture?

The question of which 2019 film should receive the accolade of Best Picture at the 2020 Academy Awards is a contentious one, with a strong case to be made for several films. The conversation often revolves around three titles: The Irishman, Marriage Story, and Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Each film brings a unique blend of talent, storytelling, and emotional resonance that cannot be ignored.

The Irishman - A Masterpiece with Heart

The Irishman, directed by Martin Scorsese, is a passion project that delves into the middle of the twentieth-century crime narrative. Scorsese has long been a household name in the film industry, and this project showcases his masterful storytelling. The film is an epic, complex tale of morality that utilizes both the mainstream and underground worlds of crime to create a compelling narrative. One of the most significant factors in its favor is the hint it will be Scorsese's final feature, potentially swaying the voters who value legacy and artistic intent highly.

The film features a stunning cast, including Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, and Joe Pesci, among others. Their performances are not only groundbreaking but also deeply emotional, making Scorsese’s film a strong contender for multiple Oscar nominations, possibly up to ten or more.

Marriage Story - Quiet Emotion and Absence of Blowouts

Marriage Story is a more delicate and subtle film that focuses on the emotional challenges of divorce. Written and directed by Noah Baumbach, the film strikes a chord with its authentic portrayal of personal and emotional turmoil. The film’s strength lies in its emotional hits, aligning with the Academy's penchant for dramas that resonate on a deep, personal level. The high-quality acting, particularly from Adam Driver and Scarlett Johansson, and well-crafted writing make it a strong contender for an Oscar in the Best Picture category.

The subtlety of Marriage Story stands in stark contrast to the more bombastic narratives of The Irishman. However, its success lies in the quieter moments that tug at the heartstrings, making it a standout in its genre.

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood - Hollywood Memes Come to Life

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, directed by Quentin Tarantino, presents a different kind of legacy. By blending nostalgia, humor, and intense violence, Tarantino reimagines the golden age of Hollywood. The film pays homage to classic films while providing an unconventional modern take, resonating with audiences' desires for a throwback to a simpler time. Its blend of star power, historical references, and Tarantino's signature style make it a crowd-pleaser, and it has all the makings of a potential Oscar winner.

While The Irishman and Marriage Story offer strong narratives and emotional depth, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood caters to a wider audience and captures the Hollywood zeitgeist. This populist appeal, combined with its box-office success, could make it a strong contender for the Best Picture award.

Other Contenders

Despite the three contenders mentioned, there are other movies that deserve recognition. Parasite, directed by Bong Joon-ho, stands out as a remarkable film that breaks genre boundaries. While it's doubtful that it will receive the Best Picture award, its unique storyline, technical mastery, and socially critical undertones make it a groundbreaking entry in the field. Similarly, Booksmart and A Portrait of a Woman in Fire offer compelling stories that may not gain significant Oscar attention but still deserve praise for their quality and impact.

Booksmart, in particular, stands out with its humor and poignant coming-of-age themes, captivating audiences while providing a social commentary on the pressures of adolescence. Conversely, A Portrait of a Woman in Fire, a powerful documentary, offers a raw and intimate perspective on the lives of women facing serious personal crises, warranting recognition for its emotional depth and social importance.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the Best Picture award is about more than just quality. It often hinges on factors such as marketing, critical reception, and cultural impact. While Marriage Story resonates with the Academy and The Irishman garners the most nominations, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is the likely frontrunner due to its cultural resonance and wide appeal. However, it's also possible that a more under-the-radar film, like Parasite, could surprise and win hearts.

As we await the 2020 Academy Awards, the predictions remain divided, making it a truly exciting time in film history.