The Ultimate Comic Book 5-Movie Collection Blu-ray: A Critical Overview

When a product comes with a claim as bold as 'The Ultimate Comic Book 5-Movie Collection,' one cannot help but be intrigued. However, in the world of superhero movies and comic book adaptations, such a claim often falls short of expectations. In this review, we will delve into the contents and quality of The Ultimate Comic Book 5-Movie Collection Blu-ray to determine if it truly lives up to its name.

Packaging and Content

Upon opening the box, one is greeted with a sturdy 5-disc case that efficiently holds the movies without taking up too much shelf space. The package includes special features from previously released editions of each movie, adding an extra layer of value. However, the true measure of quality is in the movies themselves.

Movie Analysis

Here is a breakdown of the included films and their respective scores:

The Spirit

Movie Score: F
Directed by Frank Miller, this film is a perfect example of a misfire. The movie is so bad that it's hard to believe it made it to theaters. The dialogue is laughably absurd, with scenes where the protagonist talks about dating his city. Samuel L. Jackson's performance as a Nazi-in-disguise villain adds to the confusion. Frank Miller, known for 'Sin City,' hasn't directed another film since, and it's easy to see why. This film is a must-avoid for any comic book enthusiast.

Conan

Movie Score: E-
Another misstep by Hollywood, Conan is a film that should never have been made. The story is nonsensical, and no amount of action or visual spectacle can save it. While the special effects are top-notch, the script and overall execution leave much to be desired.

Kick Ass

Movie Score: D
With a great plot and the idea of a down-on-his-luck high school student turning into a vigilante, 'Kick Ass' had a promising premise. However, the film's crude humor and overt violence overshadow the storytelling, making it less appealing to many viewers. Nicolas Cage's performance is solid, but the movie's tone and execution are off-putting for some.

The Punisher

Movie Score: B-
Directed by David Shepherd, 'The Punisher' is a mixed bag. The film does have its flaws, but it remains an enjoyable watch overall. Thomas Jane's portrayal of John Carl Grimaldi, the Punisher, is somewhat distancing, but the movie keeps the viewer engaged enough to warrant watching it.

The Crow

Movie Score: A
Perhaps the standout of the collection is 'The Crow.' Directed by Chad Stahelski, this film stands out as a dark and captivating superhero movie. It not only matches the source material, but actually improves upon it. The untimely death of star Brandon Lee still lingers over the film, but it remains a must-watch for any comic book collection.

Conclusion and Recommendation

While the Ultimate Comic Book 5-Movie Collection Blu-ray includes some watchable films, the collection is marred by at least two movies that do not live up to the hype. The overall score for this set is a C-, a typical cash grab from a company looking to capitalize on the popularity of superhero films. For those on the fence, the Dark Knight Trilogy Collectors Edition Blu-ray is still considered the ultimate comic book movie collection.

With just two of the five movies worth watching, this set may not be the best investment for serious comic book fans or collectors. However, if you are intrigued by the promise and looking for affordability, the collection offers a few gems amidst the mediocre.