The Realism Dilemma in Holiday Movies: Why They Seem So Unrealistic

Why are holiday movies so unrealistic? The question has been floating around for years, and the answer is multifaceted. In essence, the very nature of cinema and its primary function – to sell an experience – explains why we often find holiday movies to be idealized and unachievable. This article explores the reasons behind the unrealistic portrayal of family dynamics and human relationships in these films. By understanding the true purpose of these movies, we can appreciate why they often seem so far from reality.

Escapism as Paramount

When we watch holiday movies, we are typically seeking an escape from the realities of life. We pay to witness a fabricated world where families come together, differences are resolved, and everyone loves one another with unconditional warmth. The world portrayed in these movies is an idealized version, a fa?ade of perfect happiness. And that's precisely what makes them enjoyable – a break from the daily grind and the possibility of experiencing something entirely different.

The Historical Evolution of Holiday Movies

Take a quick glance back at the 1980s, and you might remember the family gatherings with love, joy, and harmony. However, those warm and fuzzy days have long since passed. Now, the only time many families come together is during Thanksgiving or Christmas, and even then, conflicts and disagreements are common. This makes holiday movies like "A Christmas Carol" and "It's a Wonderful Life" seem almost quaint in their portrayal of a perfect holiday season. In a world filled with stress and instability, these movies offer a glimmer of hope and a vision of a better future – a future where everyone is happy and lives in harmony. Although these stories may seem unrealistic, they serve to reassure us that such a world is possible.

Realism vs. Fantasy in Holiday Movies

Why do holiday movies often turn out with everyone happy at the end? It's because it sells. You can't market a product where the end result is a bittersweet or tragic conclusion. The audience wants to leave the theater with a sense of warmth, joy, and contentment. This is where movies like "Pretty Woman" come into play. Despite its unrealistic portrayal of a high-end prostitute, travelers, and wealthy businessmen, the movie still resonates with audiences because it offers a fantasy version of happiness and success. Such movies appeal to the audience's desire for an idealized world where obstacles are easily overcome and life's challenges are absent.

Critiques and Counterpoints

Some may argue that the frequent portrayal of idealized scenarios in holiday movies sets unrealistic expectations, which can lead to disappointment in real life. Take "Last Christmas," for example, which showcases an almost unattainable level of romance and happiness. However, this is where the line between fantasy and escapism becomes blurred. In a world where romance is often a fleeting and imperfect experience, these movies provide a brief respite from cynicism. They allow us to dream and believe in a better version of ourselves and our relationships. It's through these fantasies that we can find the strength to navigate the challenges of reality.

Conclusion

While it's true that many holiday movies are unrealistic, it's important to remember their purpose. They are not meant to reflect reality, but rather to provide a sense of warmth, hope, and joy. These movies can serve as a much-needed escape from the stresses of daily life, offering a glimpse into a world where everyone can live in harmony. So, the next time you find yourself questioning the realism of a holiday movie, keep in mind that you're watching a piece of art designed to bring you some comfort and happiness. In the end, that's what truly matters.