The Iron Throne Contention: Who Truly Deserves the Throne – Jon Snow or Daenerys Targaryen?

When it comes to claiming the Iron Throne of Westeros, one cannot help but ask: who truly has the better claim between Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen? The answer is complex and involves a blend of legal and moral considerations. This article will delve into the details of their claims, exploring the bloodline, legitimacy, and character that lead to their respective positions.

Daenerys Targaryen

Bloodline

Daenerys Targaryen is the last surviving member of the Targaryen dynasty, the once ruling lineage of Westeros. Her claim is based on her descent from Aegon the Conqueror, the first Targaryen king who laid the foundation of the Iron Throne. While her family fell from power and her lineage was nearly lost, her bloodline ensures her claim to the throne remains strong due to its royal heritage.

Legitimacy

Born to King Aerys II, often referred to as the Mad King, Daenerys is considered the legitimate heir to the throne despite her family's tragic downfall. Legitimacy is not just about bloodline; it involves the acceptance and recognition of authority. Despite the turmoil and war, Daenerys has spent her life believing in her right to rule and has been actively working to restore the Targaryen legacy.

Self-Identification

Daenerys has maintained her identity as a rightful queen, which is evident from her actions and efforts to reclaim the Iron Throne. Her journey from exile and slavery to becoming a mother, wife, and conqueror has been driven by her belief in her duty to rule. This unwavering commitment has also garnered her followers and support, including those who are drawn to her vision and determination.

Jon Snow

Bloodline

Jon Snow emerges as a legitimate Targaryen descendant through his discovery that he is Aegon Targaryen, the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark. This revelation through Bran Stark's visions and a maester's diary established him as a direct heir to the Iron Throne. His lineage is clear, making his claim both legal and plausible.

Stark Heritage

Unlike Daenerys, Jon was born and raised in the North, which means he carries the legacy of House Stark. This heritage could provide him with support from the North, particularly those who view him as a more relatable and noble leader. The Stark pedigree is deeply ingrained in the North's history and Jon's inclusion in this lineage could be seen as a positive factor.

Character and Leadership

While Jon Snow embodies qualities such as justice, honor, and humility, Daenerys, with her experience in ruling the Dothraki and Unsullied, has a proven track record in governance. However, her stubborn and sometimes overbearing leadership style has also faced criticism. In contrast, Jon's willingness to listen to counsel and learn from his experiences may be viewed as an advantage, offering a more adaptable and collaborative approach to leadership.

Conclusion

Legal Claim

From a legal standpoint, both Jon and Daenerys have strong claims to the Iron Throne. Daenerys' claim is based on her bloodline and the undying belief in her right to rule, while Jon's is bolstered by the revelations about his lineage and the historical records that support it.

Support and Morality

The ultimate decision may depend on who can garner more support from the people of Westeros and who best exemplifies the values that the realm expects in a ruler. The public sentiment and the effectiveness of their leadership strategies will play crucial roles in determining the future of the Iron Throne.

Summary

Both Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen have compelling claims to the Iron Throne. Their strength and effectiveness as rulers will likely be shaped by their ability to connect with the people, navigate the complex political landscape, and embody the values that the realm holds dear. The path to the Iron Throne is neither straightforward nor guaranteed, but the determination of both contenders will undoubtedly determine the outcome of their epic struggle.