The Impact of King Robert’s Decision: A Reassessment of His Actions

Would it have been better for everyone involved if King Robert had dismissed Jaime from the Kingsguard following the rebellion and instead reinstated him as Tywin Lannister's heir? This decision would have significant repercussions, altering the course of events and influencing the political landscape of the Seven Kingdoms. Let's explore the implications of a different decision made by King Robert regarding his younger brother, Jaime Lannister.

THE BIOS OF THE CHARACTERS

Jaime Lannister was a young man during the rebellion, and owing to his age, dismissing him from the Kingsguard would have been a more logical choice. However, reinstating him as Tywin's heir would shift the balance of power in the Lannister family and, by extension, the Seven Kingdoms. His replacement, though less formidable, would have their own strengths to contend with in leadership and strategic prowess.

TYWIN'S DEMISE AND THE MERCY OF KILLING

When Tywin Lannister celebrates, he achieves his objective of having Jaime back at Casterly Rock, appointed as the commander of the Lannister army and heir to the throne. The restoration of Jaime to his former position brings a sense of closure and stability for the Lannister family. This move solidifies Tywin's legacy and ensures that the Lannisters remain a formidable force in the Seven Kingdoms.

CERSEI'S FATE AND HER FAILURE

Cersei, however, faces a tragic fate. Her plan, which involves Jaime's removal, fails spectacularly. Deprived of Jaime once again, Cersei’s despair drives her to take her own life. The loss of her love and a potential heir leaves her without purpose, leading to her tragic end. This turn of events contrasts starkly with her earlier determination and cunning, highlighting the depth of her emotional vulnerability.

JAMIE’S FUTURE AND THE LIMITATION OF OPTIONS

Jaime would likely be overcome by grief and depression at the loss of Cersei. However, his resilience and strength would eventually compel him to move on with his life. Given the limited options for marriage due to the high number of casualties in the rebellion and his sisters' marriages, he might indeed consider marrying a Lannister cousin, following a family tradition. This action would further entrench the Lannister family's influence and maintain their internal unity.

SUCCESSORS AND MARRIAGES

Upon King Robert's death, the kingdom needs a new ruler. Robert had multiple children, both trueborn and bastards, which complicates succession. Lynesse Hightower or a Tyrell girl could become his new wife, thus aligning the power structures and ensuring the stability of the realm. This move would necessitate good relations with the Reach, a powerful and influential region that could either support or oppose the new consort.

THE END OF THE WAR OF THE WORLDS FROM MYTH

The War of the Five Kings as we know it would not occur if Robert had survived the rebellion. With Robert alive, Baelish would have little incentive to murder Jon Arryn. Consequently, no significant conflict similar to the War of the Five Kings would unfold, though Ned Stark’s rise as Hand of the King might still lead to poisoning attempts by Lyanna Baratheon, as she would seek to replace him.

SUBSEQUENT SCENARIOS

Robert's eventual death would bring his son, Edric Baratheon, to the throne. Edric, a tall and strong warrior, would eventually marry Sansa Stark, ensuring a strong alliance between the Baratheons and Starks. Another daughter, Lyanna Baratheon, would marry Loras Tyrell, further solidifying ties with the Reach. If Robert were to die in a hunting accident, Edric and Sansa would seamlessly transition to the thrones of King and Queen, ensuring a smooth transition of power.

POLITICAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT

The political landscape under Edric's rule would be shaped by his leadership and alliances. The Starks would remain powerful at Winterfell, keeping their forces strong and ready to counter challenges such as Mance Rayder. Alliser Thorne would remain the Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, with Jon Snow as a Black Brother. This scenario would maintain a balance of power and avoid the chaotic events seen in the War of the Five Kings.

CONCLUSION

The decisions made by King Robert have profound implications for his family, the Lannisters, and the broader political landscape of the Seven Kingdoms. By reconsidering the dismissal of Jaime and reinstating him as Tywin's heir, Robert would significantly alter the direction of the kingdom, ensuring a more stable and resilient future for the Lannisters and the realm.