The Battle of New York with Outriders Replacing Chitauri: Would They Have Won?

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), the Outriders are a formidable species created by Thanos. If they had replaced the Chitauri during the pivotal Battle of New York, would they have emerged victorious? Let's delve into the various factors that would influence the outcome.

Tactics and Coordination

The Chitauri displayed a degree of coordinated strategic planning and were led by Loki. Their organized attacks allowed them to maintain a semblance of control on the battlefield. In contrast, the Outriders operate more like a swarm, lacking the complex planning and strategic cohesion seen in the Chitauri. This could result in disorganization, chaos, and a lack of cohesive military units, which might hinder their effectiveness.

Leadership

Under Loki's command, the Chitauri had a clear plan to conquer Earth. His leadership was crucial in orchestrating their operations and maintaining control. Should the Outriders have attempted to invade without the guidance of a strong and strategic leader, their efforts might have been disorganized and ineffective. Without a clear leader directing their attacks, the Outriders could have struggled to mount a cohesive and coordinated assault.

The Avengers

The Avengers were well-prepared for the Chitauri invasion, with a clear plan in place. If the Outriders had invaded instead, the Avengers would have still had time to adapt and develop a counter-strategy. Characters such as Iron Man and the Hulk, with their advanced weaponry and sheer physical strength, could have been particularly effective against the Outriders in their swarm-like tactics. The Avengers' teamwork and unique abilities would have likely resulted in a strategic advantage over the Outriders.

Capabilities

The Chitauri were technologically advanced and equipped with formidable weaponry. In contrast, the Outriders, while powerful and numerous, lack the advanced technology and aerial capabilities that the Chitauri possessed. This technological disparity would have limited the Outriders' effectiveness, especially in the urban environment of New York, where strategic positioning and aerial combat played crucial roles. The Avengers would have had an advantage in maneuvering through the cityscape and utilizing their advanced gadgets to counter the Outriders.

Conclusion

While the Outriders, with their sheer numbers and ferocity, could pose a significant threat, their lack of strategic leadership and advanced capabilities might ultimately lead to a different outcome than that of the Chitauri invasion. The battle would likely have been more chaotic, but the Avengers would still find a way to prevail, albeit with greater difficulty. The absence of strategic planning and effective leadership could hamper the Outriders' efforts, making it unlikely for them to achieve a victory similar to the Chitauri's.