The Aftermath of Roberts Rebellion: What if Aerys II Targaryen Had Won?

In the intricate world of Westeros, the outcome of Roberts Rebellion is a pivotal point in the history of the realm. If Aerys II Targaryen, known as the Mad King, had emerged victorious instead, the consequences would have been profound and far-reaching. This article delves into the various potential outcomes that could have reshaped the political landscape of Westeros.

1. Continued Targaryen Rule vs. Ongoing Instability

Stability vs. Chaos: Aerys' victory could have solidified Targaryen rule in the short term. However, his erratic behavior and paranoia might have fueled ongoing instability. His cruel and paranoid rule could have intensified, leading to a series of internal power struggles and rebellion.

2. Impact on the Great Houses

House Targaryen

The Targaryens: The Targaryens might have regained some of their former power. Aerys' reputation, however, would still loom large. His continued reign would likely lead to further dissent among the nobility, as his madness and cruelty would continue to affect their allegiances.

House Baratheon

House Baratheon: Robert Baratheon's claim to the throne would be extinguished. As a result, House Baratheon could face severe repercussions, with their lands possibly stripped or given to loyalists of the crown. Aerys might also seek to eliminate other key rebel leaders, leading to a complex political landscape.

House Stark

House Stark: The Starks, who supported the rebellion, would likely face punishment. This could lead to long-standing tensions and a potential loss of Northern autonomy. The animosity between the Starks and other houses might deepen, setting the stage for future conflicts.

3. The Role of the Lannisters

Cersei and Jaime's Future: If the Lannisters had supported Aerys successfully, Cersei and Jaime might have been positioned more favorably within the court. Tywin Lannister's influence could grow, possibly leading to a more tyrannical rule. The animosity between the Starks and Lannisters would likely escalate, setting the stage for further conflicts.

4. The Fate of the Targaryen Dynasty

Daenerys and Viserys: If Aerys had won, the fates of Daenerys and Viserys could have been very different. They might have remained in Westeros, potentially used as pawns in Aerys' political games. Their survival could be tenuous, as they would be under constant threat from Aerys and his loyalists.

Future Targaryen Generations: The survival of the Targaryen bloodline could be secure, but the legacy of Aerys' madness might cast a long shadow over future rulers. Any claim to the throne by a Targaryen would be met with heightened skepticism and fear, leading to instability and potential conflict.

5. The Iron Throne and the Realm

Political Climate: The realm would likely remain divided with various factions supporting or plotting against Aerys. The political landscape would become even more treacherous, with alliances shifting and power struggles becoming ever more complex. The common people and nobility might become increasingly resentful of Aerys' rule, leading to future uprisings or rebellions.

6. Dragons and Magic

Return of Dragons: If Aerys retained his power, his dragons (if any remained) would be a means of terror and control, reinforcing his rule. The presence of dragons and magic could play a significant role in shaping the political dynamics of Westeros, influencing both allies and enemies.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Aerys' winning of Roberts Rebellion would have led to a complex web of political intrigue, power struggles, and potential chaos as the realm adjusted to a reasserted Targaryen rule. The long-term stability of Westeros would remain uncertain, with the possibility of future conflicts brewing beneath the surface. The legacy of Aerys' madness would loom large, casting a shadow over the future of the realm.