Reimaging the Fallout of Jon Snow, Stannis Baratheon, and Tormund's Deaths on Westeros

The events of the A Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin are filled with pivotal moments that shape the narrative of Westeros. Imagine the drastic changes that could have occurred had some of the key characters, such as Jon Snow, Stannis Baratheon, and Tormund Giantsbane, perished during the critical battle at Castle Black. Here's a speculative exploration of the possible ripple effects of these deaths.

The Impact of Stannis Baratheon's Death

If Stannis died during the initial stages of the battle, it would significantly impact the morale of his army. Which means his forces might retreat preemptively, giving the wildlings an opportunity to overwhelm the Night's Watch. However, it is possible that his defeat and death would lead to Shireen becoming the new claimant to the Iron Throne, with the loyal support of Melisandre and her mother.

Given her young age and the potential threat posed by the White Walkers, Shireen's survival is highly questionable. She may either be killed or eventually set aside, thus removing any legitimate claim to the throne. This could also lead to a power vacuum, with disorganized leadership potentially aiding the wildlings in their conquest.

The Case of Tormund Giantsbane

The loss of Tormund, in isolation, might not have as significant an effect on the narrative, especially if Mance Rayner survived. What makes Tormund important is his relationship with Jon Snow. His death could further exacerbate the rift between the wildlings and the Night's Watch, making the wildlings less amenable to negotiations.

The Critical Role of Jon Snow

But the real scandal lies in the hypothetical death of Jon Snow. If Jon Snow were to die at Castle Black, then the outcome of the war against the White Walkers would be immensely altered. Without him, the Night's Watch would be left in questionable hands, such as Janis Slynt or Ser Alister Thorne, who would have no interest in making alliances with the wildlings.

Consequences for Westeros

Jon Snow is the linchpin in the series, crucial for both the defensive efforts against the White Walkers and the various alliances forged between houses and wildling leaders. Here are a few potential outcomes if Jon were to die:

Should Janis Slynt or Ser Alister Thorne become Lord Commander, they would likely escalate tensions with the wildlings, leading to further atrocities. This would push the wildlings at Hardhome to become wights, contributing to the growing army of the dead.

Sansa Stark would likely be handed back to the Boltons, as there would be no one at Castle Black to offer sanctuary to the remaining members of House Stark from the North.

Even if Sansa reclaimed the North with the help of House Arryn, she would not be aware of the impending threat of the White Walkers. Any news about the threat coming from non-trusted sources might be easily dismissed.

Missing Alliances and Resources

Jon's influence was crucial in forming alliances and securing resources. Without him:

No attempts would be made to forge an alliance with other southern claimants such as Cersei Lannister, Daenerys Targaryen (or Aegon Targaryen), or even Cersei in the books. There would be no effort to source and mine dragonglass.

Arya Stark would not head back to the North, as her journey to the Wall was significant and played a crucial role in the eventual defeat of the White Walkers.

Without Jon, Dany (or Aegon) would fully embrace the idea of "fire and blood," and Jon, as her lover and lieutenant, would have dissuaded her from this approach, thus preventing the potential destruction of Westeros.

Final Consequences

In summary, the deaths of Jon Snow, Stannis Baratheon, and Tormund Giantsbane could lead to disastrous outcomes for Westeros. The failure to prevent the White Walkers' invasion would ultimately result in the downfall of the series, 'A Song of Ice and Fire,' and potentially, the end of Westeros as we know it.

Conclusion

The deaths of these key characters during the Battle of Castle Black would fundamentally alter the trajectory of the series. The absence of Jon Snow, Stannis Baratheon, and Tormund could result in a dark and devastating end to the saga, leaving Westeros vulnerable to the forces of evil.