Why the Misunderstanding About Captain America Kissing His Granddaughter in Captain America: Civil War?

Many viewers of the Marvel film series, particularly Captain America: Civil War, have wondered if Captain America actually kissed his own granddaughter. This confusion primarily stems from a scene involving Steve Rogers sharing a romantic moment with Sharon Carter, who is portrayed by Emily VanCamp. However, Sharon Carter is not actually Captain America’s granddaughter - she is the great-niece of Peggy Carter, Steve Rogers’ first love.

The Relationship Between Steve and Sharon Carter

Several times, it has been clarified that Sharon Carter is not Steve's granddaughter. She is the granddaughter of Peggy Carter's late brother, making her the great-niece of Peggy. There is no blood relation between Steve and Sharon, which is why the romantic scene may have been misunderstood as a kiss to a family member.

Steve's Motivation for the Kiss

It is commonly speculated that Steve Rogers kissed Sharon Carter because she reminded him of Peggy Carter. This could be interpreted as a "in the moment" kind of action, where Steve was not necessarily acting on a romantic interest but rather a deep emotional connection. This explanation aligns with Steve's character, who often has a soft spot for Peggy despite the time that has passed between them.

Support for the Explanation

Many fans and commentators have supported the idea that Captain America’s kiss was not inappropriate or unsettling. It's argued that powerful older men often have relationships with much younger women, and that such relationships are not necessarily bio-crimes, as long as they are consensual and maintained in appropriate social contexts.

Comparisons to Real-World Examples

Some have drawn parallels to real-world examples, such as the film career of Woody Allen, where the line between professional and personal relationships can sometimes blur. However, it is emphasized that the relationship between Captain America and Sharon Carter is not as concerning as those involving more complex situations, such as a quantum realm debut of Ant-Man and an older version of Cassie after the Snap.

Conclusion

Scott Lang, also known as Ant-Man, is a clear example of the complexity that can arise in real-world situations involving relationships and time. However, in the context of Captain America: Civil War, there is no issue with Steve Rogers and Sharon Carter's relationship. The confusion primarily arises from the misinterpretation of Sharon's character and her relation to Peggy Carter.

The film's narrative and thematic focus on the conflict between superheroes and the implications of the Sokovia Accords, along with the peripheral nature of the romantic subplot involving Sharon Carter, means that such discussions are less prominent. However, the deeper dive into the relationship dynamics offers a fascinating look at how complex emotions and memories can manifest in unexpected ways.