Is Peter Capaldi Too Old for Jenna Coleman in Doctor Who?

The pairing of Peter Capaldi and Jenna Coleman in Doctor Who sparked some discussions about age differences in the context of their roles. Capaldi, who played the Twelfth Doctor, was born in 1958, while Coleman, who portrayed Clara Oswald, was born in 1986. This 28-year age gap led some viewers to question whether the romantic tension between their characters was unusual given the Doctor's typically youthful persona.

Historical Precedent in Doctor Who

However, Doctor Who has a long history of showcasing relationships that transcend age differences. The Doctor's character is not bound by human norms as he is a Time Lord with a unique perspective on time and relationships. The dynamic between Capaldi's Doctor and Coleman's Clara was more about companionship, adventure, and emotional connection rather than a conventional romantic relationship.

Views on the Pairing

Ultimately, while some fans questioned the pairing, others appreciated the depth and complexity it brought to the series. The show often explores themes of friendship and loyalty, which can resonate regardless of age.

Unconventional Soulmates

Some have argued that their relationship was not just about romance. As Laura from the original text explains, 'You dont have to be hooked up to be a soulmate. I have 2. One is my husband but the other is my best friend since primary school. Laura and I were inseparable and knew what the other was saying or thinking. For 52 years, weve been the same.'

Character Dynamics and Companionship

In the context of Doctor Who, Clara was the beloved of the Doctor because she was sprinkled through his timeline and each time she saved him, sometimes sacrificing her own life. The Doctor was beloved of Clara because he was the one person she could count on for support. The Doctor allowed Clara to step out of what people believed she should be. Unfortunately, at the end, she took one too many risks and took on the Raven.

For many fans, the Twelfth Doctor will always be their favorite Doctor. No one will ever reach Capaldi's portrayal of the Doctor and Clara will always be their favorite companion. The two of them together, the Daleks and cybermen stood no chance against their formidable partnership.

Conclusion

The age difference between Capaldi and Coleman didn't diminish their dynamic and impact on Doctor Who. Their relationship was more about mutual support, trust, and the emotional bond that transcended conventional categorizations of romance.