Is Magic Real for a Fantasy World?

The question of whether magic is real often attracts much discussion, starting from academic criticisms of its non-scientific nature to passionate arguments for its real existence. However, the definitions and contexts in which 'magic' is discussed can greatly impact this debate. This article examines the role of magic in fantasy, its historical development, and the scientific vs. mystical perspectives.

The Definition of Magic

One common misconception is that magic as defined in pop-culture fantasy—novels, TV, and movies—is nonsense. While this may be true in a strict scientific sense, dismissing magic outright is a mistake. The term magic has evolved over time, changing as our understanding of the world around us has expanded. Virtually everything considered science today was once seen as a form of occultism or magic.

Shifting Definitions

From the development of chemistry, psychology, astronomy, and even medicinal herblore, historical changes in our understanding have reshaped what we consider scientific and occult. For instance, the understanding of radiation and radio waves were once considered magical, but now are studied and understood through the scientific method. The very act of experimenting and measuring has transformed these phenomena from the mystical to the mundane.

This transformation has profound implications for our understanding of magic. It is not just a matter of dismissing the idea outright but recognizing the progression of understanding that has led to our current scientific knowledge. Just as the scientific understanding of the world has evolved, so has our understanding of magic.

The Role of Magic in Fantasy

In the realm of fantasy, magic is often a central element that shapes the narrative and the world. Fantasy as a genre exists to explore and celebrate the occult in a way that science fiction does with technology. Characters who possess magical powers often embody the antithesis of the rational, tapping into unforeseen powers that challenge the known order of the world.

Personal Experience and Perception

Those who dismiss magic often do so based on a lack of personal experience or rigorous study. Like an advanced musician can read a Baroque masterpiece, an experienced magician can see the potential in magic that the uninitiated cannot. The experiences of magic and the occult can fundamentally change one's view of existence and interaction with the world.

Historical Context and Skepticism

Throughout history, cultures have believed to have all the answers, only to realize later that there is more to discover and learn. This is evident in the advancements of science and technology, where what was once considered magic is now understood through rigorous experimentation. This development is a reminder that our understanding of the world is constantly evolving.

Lessons from History

Reflecting on history, we see that our understanding of magic is continually expanding. From the invention of the lightbulb to the development of radio and other communication technologies, what was once thought to be impossible is now a part of our daily lives. This evolution highlights the importance of not dismissing the possibility of magic out of hand.

The Future of Magic

For those who are curious about the occult and magic, there is much to explore. The fear of societal judgment should not deter us from seeking knowledge, just as history has shown. Engaging with topics that are often misunderstood can lead to profound insights and personal growth. The journey of inquiry, whether into the occult or other less understood fields, can be both enlightening and transformative.

Advice: Learn to deal with the fear of judgment and continue your path of exploration. The journey can offer more lessons and experiences than the destination. Remember the teachings of Buddhism: you may learn more on the way than at the end. Let go of expectations and embrace the journey.

Further Reading:

J.S. Valentine’s Answer to What is the Scientific Rational Explanation of the Occult Practices, Black Magic, and Rituals?

Blessings