Is It Worth Investing in Beatles Rarities US Version?: A Comprehensive Overview

Is it worth it to invest in Beatles Rarities US version album if I own Beatles Anthologies in my collection?

r r

Is It Worth Investing in Beatles Rarities US Version?

r r

Deciding whether to invest in the Beatles Rarities US version (often referred to simply as ldquo;Raritiesrdquo;) can be a complex dilemma, especially if you already own the Beatles Anthologies in your collection. This article aims to provide a comprehensive analysis by breaking down the considerations and highlighting the unique value that the Rarities US version offers.

r r

Completist Interest and Completeness

r r

Whether the investment in the Rarities US version is worthwhile largely depends on how much of a completist you are. For collectors who aim to cover every possible variation of the Beatlesrsquo; music, the Rarities US version might be a valuable addition to your collection. However, for others, it might be redundant if you already have many other Beatles records in your possession.

r r

Unique Tracks on the Rarities US Version

r r

The Rarities US version is particularly interesting for its unique tracks that are not available on other Beatles albums. Specifically, there are three standout tracks:

r r

1. ldquo;And I Love Herrdquo;

r r

ldquo;And I Love Herrdquo; features six extra beats, which sets it apart from other versions. This track comes from a German release. The US version adds this extra element, making it a unique and valuable addition for completists interested in every possible variation.

r r

2. ldquo;I Am the Walrusrdquo;

r r

This track is a new edit from the Capitol stereo and mono mixes, offering extra beats in the intro and before the verse that begins ldquo;Yellow matter custard.rdquo; These versions were previously available on the 8-LP 1980 box set The Beatles Box but are now only available on the Rarities US version.

r r

3. ldquo;Penny Lanerdquo;

r r

The Rarities US version includes a new stereo edit of ldquo;Penny Lanerdquo; that adds the final trumpet flourish from a mono version released to selected US radio stations. This unique flourish is only available on the Rarities US version of this song, making it a valuable component of the collection.

r r

Comparison with Beatles Anthologies

r r

The Beatles Anthologies include a wide range of songs and live performances from the band. While these albums are fantastic, they do not cover every possible variation of the songs you might find on the Rarities US version. For example, the Rarities US version includes the six extra beats on ldquo;And I Love Herrdquo; and the unique mono trumpet flourish on ldquo;Penny Lane.rdquo;

r r

Availability of Other Versions

r r

Itrsquo;s worth noting that while these unique tracks are indeed special, they are also available in other formats. For instance, the 1980 box set The Beatles Box included the new edit of ldquo;I Am the Walrusrdquo;, which added the extra beats in the intro. The mono version of ldquo;Penny Lanerdquo; with the final trumpet flourish is available on the deluxe edition of Sgt. Pepperrsquo;s Lonely Hearts Club Band 50th Anniversary. However, the US Rarities version offers these elements in a convenient album format, rather than across multiple releases.

r r

Closing Thoughts

r r

To sum it up, whether it is worth investing in the Beatles Rarities US version depends on your level of completeness and interest in collecting every possible variation of the Beatlesrsquo; music. If you are a completist, or if you value the convenience of a single collection featuring these unique tracks, then the Rarities US version could be a valuable addition to your collection. Otherwise, you might find that the Beatles Anthologies are sufficient for your needs.