House of the Dragon: Reassessing Criston Cole's Character After His Order to Kill Rhaenyra Targaryen

Introduction

House of the Dragon, a gripping prequel to Game of Thrones, has introduced viewers to a plethora of complex characters. One of the most controversial figures is Criston Cole, particularly after he ordered Ser Arryk Cargyll to kill Princess Rhaenyra Targaryen. This article delves into the nuances of Criston Cole's character, urging viewers to reconsider their stance on him after this pivotal scene.

Initial Controversy: Cole's Involvement in Jaehaerys' Murder

The order to kill Rhaenyra Targaryen is a dark moment in Criston Cole's character, but it's crucial to remember the circumstances leading up to this decision. In one of the show's most controversial moments, Criston Cole was found with Queen Dowager Visenya, not getting the help he supposedly came for. This act alone paints a picture of a man who prioritizes his personal desires over his responsibilities, not to mention his hypocritical behavior toward Rhaenyra later in the episode.

A Closer Look at Cole's Hypocrisy and Fault Lines

Indeed, Criston Cole is a deeply flawed character, and his order to Ser Arryk Cargyll to kill Rhaenyra is but one of many instances of his moral bankruptcy. During the murder of Prince Jaehaerys, Cole was found engaged in an act with the queen, clearly in a position of intimacy, rather than helping the prince. This act alone is a testament to his hypocrisy, as it shows him prioritizing his personal desires over his responsibilities. Cole then has the audacity to transfer the blame onto Ser Arryk, a character who was, and is, committed to Rhaenyra, falsely accusing Arryk of being motivated by his allegiance to her.

It's worth noting the irony in Cole's actions. While he ordered Arryk to carry out a ruthless act, he himself was making a significant promise to himself and his people, which required him to stay at Dragonstone without casualties. It's illogical to believe that Cole would have thought Arryk could complete the mission without resistance, while simultaneously ensuring his own safety. This duality in behavior underscores Cole's unstable and morally ambiguous persona.

Implications and Reevaluation

Viewers who are sympathetic to Criston Cole after this scene may need to reconsider their stance. The order to kill Rhaenyra Targaryen is a heinous act, and Cole's failure to stand up against such a directive further cements his role as a deceitful and selfish character. It's easy to understand why some viewers may still find a redeeming quality in him, as the act itself is devastating and emotional. However, it's important to remember that actions have consequences, and Cole's subsequent actions, or lack thereof, ultimately shape his character.

The order to kill Rhaenyra is not just a one-off event. It's a crucial moment in the narrative that highlights the depth of Cole's moral corruption and his willingness to go to great lengths to protect his own interests. This episode serves as a turning point, likely permanently changing the perception of this once-potential romantic interest for Rhaenyra.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the order to kill Rhaenyra Targaryen is a pivotal moment that forces viewers to reassess Criston Cole's character. It is an act that reveals the true nature of a man who prioritizes his desires over his duties and who is more than willing to exploit others, especially those under his command. As House of the Dragon continues, Cole's actions will no doubt have serious repercussions, both for his legacy and for the political landscape of Westeros.

The key to understanding Cole is to see him as a fully realized, morally complex character. His bloodlust and selfishness are on full display, making his future actions in the show all the more intriguing and consequential.