Choosing Between Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts

When it comes to choosing between Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts, opinions are divided, much like the allegiance to either Hogwarts or Newt Scamander. Both series offer unique experiences and have carved their own place in the Wizarding World. Each has its own strengths, and deciding which to prefer often revolves around personal preferences and the context in which one views the stories.

Why I Prefer Harry Potter

If you consider me, the decision leans heavily towards Harry Potter. There are several reasons for this. Harry Potter has birthed an entire universe, one that has spawned Fantastic Beasts, sequels, video games, and countless fan theories. The main character, Harry Potter, is a celebrated hero, a symbol of courage, and resilience against dark magic. However, the story surrounding Harry comes with its fair share of sadness and tragic undertones. The series deals with the loss of loved ones, friendship, and the weight of the world on one young boy. Despite this, Harry Potter remains a series that teaches valuable lessons about love, sacrifice, and the enduring power of hope.

Why I Prefer Fantastic Beasts

Conversely, the allure of Fantastic Beasts lies in its complexity and depth. Newt Scamander, the protagonist of Fantastic Beasts, is not just an adventurer; he is a man with his own struggles. Although he may not be the obvious hero that Harry is, Newt's character is rich with layers, making him a more intriguing figure. Newt's achievements, such as his successful extension of habitats for magical creatures and his valiant fight against Gellert Grindelwald, showcase his strength and cunning. Unlike Harry, who is almost magically destined to fulfill his prophecy, Newt's story is about choice and the grace under pressure. These qualities make Newt a more compelling and relatable hero, one who grows and evolves throughout the series.

The Differences in the Series

A direct comparison between Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts is challenging, given that they exist in different eras within the Wizarding World. While Harry Potter covers the time from the age of 11 to 17, focusing on the trials faced by the Golden Trio, Fantastic Beasts offers a glimpse into the time before Harry, exploring the adventures of Newt and the greater threat of Grindelwald. The era in which the stories take place makes a significant difference, as it influences the characters' backgrounds and personalities.

Personal Experiences and Favorites

According to Twila Di Angelo, the love for Harry Potter goes beyond simple enjoyment. "I watch Harry Potter because I love it. I know a lot about it, I have a book about her, and my dad once met Daniel Radcliffe in the dressing room while he was fixing a light."

While some argue that nothing can fully replace the original Harry Potter movies, others acknowledge the value of Fantastic Beasts. The question is not about one series being better than the other but rather about appreciating them in their own right. J.K. Rowling herself has stated, 'It's a matter of which one you're into. Fantastic Beasts fans and Harry Potter fans have different tastes and alignments, and both are valid.'

The Conclusion

Ultimately, choosing between Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts boils down to individual preferences and the deeper connection to the characters and stories. Both series offer unique experiences and valuable lessons. For some, the journey of the Golden Trio holds the heart, while for others, the adventures of Newt Scamander represent a different kind of magic. In the end, the choice is not about which is better, but rather which series resonates with you the most.