Character Analysis and Dialogue Placement in Harry Potter: Who Should Say It?

The question of who should say certain lines in the Harry Potter series often sparks debate among fans. This article explores the specific example of a dialogue regarding Remus Lupin's true identity as a werewolf, and evaluates which character would be most fitting to deliver this line.

Context and Significance

The Harry Potter series, created by J.K. Rowling, is renowned for its well-developed characters and intricate plot twists. One such pivotal moment revolves around the revelation that Remus Lupin, a seemingly benevolent and trusted character, is actually a werewolf and a member of the Order of the Phoenix, working against Voldemort. The films' portrayal of this subplot, particularly the Prisoner of Azkaban film, often raises questions about dialogue decisions and character interactions.

The Dialogical Analysis

The specific line in question is crafted to convey realization and self-blame. Hermione, in the third book, says, "If I was clever, I would have told you before Harry, but I thought you could probably figure out Lupin's secret yourself." This line is aimed to show Hermione's brilliance and her initial trust in Harry to handle the situation.

However, in the movie adaptation, the dialogue is slightly altered, with Hermione taking the line: "If I was clever, I would have told you, Harry, but I thought you could probably figure out Lupin on your own." This change has sparked considerable discussion among fans about which character would be more appropriate to say this line.

Character Suitability

Hermione Granger

Hermione Granger, characterized as the smartest of the trio, would likely come to this realization first. Her intelligence and studious nature make her the most logical candidate to figure out Lupin's werewolf identity. However, given her strong bond with Ron and Harry, and her patient, supportive nature, it seems unusual for her to express doubt in their combined abilities. Her line also aligns with the book version, suggesting her to be the most fitting character for the original dialogue.

Harry Potter

Harry, on the other hand, had a deeper relationship with Lupin. He spent significant time with him, learning defensive magic and forming a trust-based relationship. This trust makes Harry more likely to believe in Lupin before the truth is revealed. Given Harry's impulsive and straightforward nature, it would be more fitting for him to express self-doubt and regret for not seeing through Lupin's deception sooner.

Why Harry Fits Best

Firstly, Harry's relationship with Remus Lupin was more personal. Harry had spent time with Lupin, learning from him and forming a strong bond. This bond suggests trust and a closer relationship compared to Hermione's, even though Hermione is generally more perceptive. Additionally, Harry's being hot-headed and his tendency to jump to conclusions without fully understanding the situation make him a more plausible figure to express this line of self-doubt.

Secondly, Harry was deeply affected by the accusations against Sirius Black. His anger towards Sirius, who wasprecedentedly becoming friends with Lupin, made Harry even more susceptible to believe that Lupin was a trustworthy friend. This emotional angle strengthens the case for Harry to deliver the line, as it aligns with his character arc and emotional journey.

Lastly, the hint of ultimate betrayal against someone he trusted highlights Harry's emotional vulnerability and the depth of his realization, making it a fitting scene for him.

Conclusion

While both Hermione and Harry could potentially say this line, Harry's unique relationship with Lupin, his impulsive nature, and the personal impact of the betrayal make him the more suitable choice. The dialogue's placement in the film, modified to Harry, serves to emphasize Harry's evolving trust and the complexity of the characters' relationships within the story.

Fan discussions often revolve around the nuances of character development and the subtleties of scriptwriting. Understanding the rationale behind character choices can enhance the enjoyment and engagement with the story, adding a layer of deepening analysis to the beloved Harry Potter series.