A Complex Decision: Choosing the Fate of an Avengers Character

In the immortal words of the Beat poets, 'What if you were given a choice?' If told an Avenger had to die in Avengers: Endgame, who would you choose to sacrifice for the greater good, and why?

Steve Rogers: The Last Stand

Steve Rogers, aka Captain America, was a man out of his time. Destined to fight in a world beyond his comprehension, he often struggled to find his place in an ever-changing world. In Avengers: Endgame, his final act was a bittersweet one—finding closure and achieving the peace he craved. Yet, if things were different, if he had to face his mortality under less heroic circumstances, I believe it would have affirmed his loyalty and sacrifice even more.

'Would you have chosen for Steve Rogers to be the casualty in a dignified manner, or is there a different Avenger whose sacrifice would resonate even more?' Read on to explore the unconventional choices and the critical impact a well-executed death scene could have.

Personality and Motivations

When faced with the seemingly random idea of which Avenger should die, one striking choice emerges: Captain Marvel. It’s not a hatred of the character, but rather a desire to see her transform into a true hero in her final moments.

The Power of Sacrifice

Confronting Thanos, the supreme villain of Avengers: Endgame, Captain Marvel would face the ultimate challenge. Her final stand would not be against the seemingly invincible Anti-Monitor, but rather Thanos himself. This scenario would be a beacon of hope and courage—a symbol of sacrifice for the greater good.

The Battle of Will and Power

In this pivotal scene, Carol Danvers—Captain Marvel—would stand face-to-face with the omnipotent Thanos. The Gauntlet crackles with power, and Thanos stands triumphant. Carol, however, shows no signs of backing down. She begins to punch Thanos with the same ferocity and unwavering determination as Supergirl faced the Anti-Monitor.

Thanos knocks Carol away with disdain. She, however, does not stay down. Instead, she counters his attack with equal strength, her blows cracking his armor and leaving her badly hurt. Despite the injuries, she continues to fight. Her actions are a testament to her selflessness and her unwavering commitment to justice.

The Limit of Her True Power

Thanos, recognizing the unusual bravery of his opponent, activates the Power Stone to clear the battlefield. Carol is the only one who remains, fully aware of her limitations. However, her determination allows her to distract Thanos and keep him from finishing his snap. Her actions, though futile in the grand scheme, buy precious time for the other heroes to escape.

Truly, this scene would be a demonstration of her true power, her willingness to risk everything to protect others, and her ultimate sacrifice.

The Ultimate Redemption

Inexplicably, unknown to both Carol and Thanos, the battle field could literally shake through time as the Time Stone-a single Infinity Stone-Carol manages to pry off the Gauntlet. This action, although it might not have completely stopped Thanos, would have prevented the ultimate snap. Her sacrifice would buy the universe a few more seconds, more than enough to allow the heroes to escape.

The Impact of Her Death

Posthumously, Carol’s sacrifice would be mourned. Her bravery and selflessness would be celebrated, turning her into a true hero. She would symbolize the ultimate challenge, a tribute to the vastness of the universe, and a reminder of the power and importance of sacrifice.

Even staunch critics of the character would be moved to silence after witnessing such an event. Perhaps, this scene would be the most memorable moment of the film, with fans seeing her greatest heroism and haters seeing her final stand.

Would such a scene make Captain Marvel the most memorable Avenger in Avengers: Endgame? It is a bold decision, but one that would certainly resonate with audiences worldwide.