A Comparative Analysis of 80s Werewolf Movies: 'An American Werewolf in London' and 'The Howling'

When it comes to classic werewolf movies from the 1980s, two titles often come to mind: An American Werewolf in London and The Howling. While both films are beloved, they each have their strengths and weaknesses. In this article, we will delve into what makes each film special and offer a balanced comparison to help determine which one reigns supreme.

Personal Preferences and Initial Impressions

Both movies are considered fan favorites, but An American Werewolf in London (AWIL) holds a special place in many hearts due to Tim Curry's charismatic performance and Dennis Dugan's iconic direction. The phrase 'AWIL' is still celebrated among horror fans, particularly those who remember the film's cult following and its enduring charm. On the other hand, The Howling was appreciated for its casting and clever storyline, although some aspects of it have aged somewhat.

Comparing the Werewolf Transformations and Effects

An American Werewolf in London is often cited for its superior special effects, which still impress today. The werewolf transformations are not only realistic but also manage to strike a balance between grotesque and shocking without crossing the line into gratuitousness. In contrast, The Howling faces criticism for some of its effects, particularly the transition scenes during intimate moments, which have been called clichéd by some viewers.

Cultural References and Humor

An American Werewolf in London is recognized for its clever references to classic Universal horror films and its werewolf lore, which adds depth to the narrative. The humor in The Howling, especially the send-ups of new age spirituality, is also noted for its effectiveness in providing a satirical edge to the werewolf genre. Both films manage to pull off different types of humor, with The Howling shining in its social commentary and witty performances.

Character Development and Storylines

While The Howling is praised for its engaging storyline and the clever character arcs, particularly the subplot involving an undead woman offering advice to the protagonist, An American Werewolf in London falls short in its character development, particularly in the climactic ending where the protagonist is killed. In contrast, The Howling offers a more satisfying conclusion that avoids a disappointing wrap-up, thanks to its final twist that catches the audience off guard.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Overall, An American Werewolf in London edges out The Howling in terms of overall quality and lasting impact. However, The Howling remains a worthy contender and perhaps even a closer second in the hearts of many werewolf movie fans. Other notable werewolf films such as The Company of Wolves and Wolfen contribute to the rich tapestry of 80s werewolf cinema, adding to its enduring legacy.

In summary, while both films have their distinct merits, An American Werewolf in London stands out as a classic of the genre, while The Howling offers a great alternative with its own set of strengths. Both are essential viewing for werewolf movie enthusiasts and fans of classic horror.